• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Muldoon's on Main

At Muldoon's on Main, a vibrant New American pub located in Carmel, history and flavor collide in an inviting atmosphere. As a women-owned establishment, it prides itself on serving diverse, mouthwatering dishes like expertly seasoned sandwiches and fresh salads, all with a hearty dose of hospitality. Guests can enjoy casual dining, outdoor seating, and happy hour specials that beckon patrons to unwind. Whether it's a tenderloin sandwich that leaves you craving more or giant onion rings that are an experience in themselves, Muldoon's offers a distinctive blend of flavors and community spirit, making it a cherished favorite for families and friends alike.

Muldoon's on Main: Reviews & Ratings

Erin S.
Erin S.

Booze? - check Friendly staff? - check Super tasty chicken quesadilla? - check Making friends with a couple older gentlemen at the bar? - check Dope music? - check Big fan

Julian H.
Julian H.

Dawn and Brenda are amazing. Great guinness pours, great wings and amazing value for Sunday Brunch!

Jayden D.
Jayden D.

I was impressed by the food here, but service was hit or miss. Came in on a Friday night, and my wife and I were seated quickly. Place was quite busy, but not too loud where we felt like we had to yell at each other to talk. Took a bit for our waitress to greet us. Also took some time to get our drinks, and our waitress only checked on us once or twice the rest of the evening (wasn't even the one who brought us our food). Food was delicious. I started off with a house salad with balsamic. Vegetables tasted fresh, and was a good quality balsamic dressing. I had a breaded tenderloin sandwich. One of the better tenderloins I've had- well seasoned and cooked to a nice crisp. Fries were good- nothing to write home about. Will definitely return for another tenderloin- hope service is better for us next time.

Sam U.
Sam U.

Good burgers with giant onion rings. I was not emotionally prepared for how giant these onion rings were going to be, they said two on the menu and I was a little disappointed but honestly, I could not even finish the two. The pictures do not do them justice. The burger was juicy and as an onion ring connoisseur, these rings were top-notch. Service was great and I will definitely be back to smash some more burgers.

Aaron D.
Aaron D.

Always a great experience and great food at Muldoon's. My trout was excellent and my kids both enjoyed their meals. My son ate the desert by himself, lol .

Maggie S.
Maggie S.

We loved Muldoon's! I went with my husband and we sat I. The enclosed, warm outdoor patio. It was fun to watch the Carmel happenings and the service was great. We ordered the 9 layer dip, split the Buffalo chicken sandwich with tater tots, and had IPAs on tap and whiskey sours. Food was delicious. We will be back!

Laura M.
Laura M.

Stopped for lunch the other day. They have a great patio to enjoy the weather and watch a game. Since it's an Irish pub I went with the fish and chips and a Guinness. They did a good pour which is important. The fish and chips were 3 pieces of fish and a good amount of chips. Nicely fried and tasty. They have a good sized menu primarily pub food such as sandwiches, burgers, salads etc. About 4 meals that would be considered traditional Irish fare. Service was ok and our server was nice.

Ashley E.
Ashley E.

Muldoon's is hands down my favorite place to get a tenderloin so when I saw Hamilton County's Tenderloin Tuesdays return I knew this was an easy stop. I've had a tenderloin at Muldoon's every time I've been there except once, so it's easy for me to say they're fantastic! There was a wait outside, but we were fine sitting inside since it was so hot. Our server was friendly and we got our food quickly after putting in our orders! I got the Mini Tenderloin which is still almost too big to eat in one sitting! Definitely don't skip Muldoon's if you're looking for a great tenderloin.

Dustin G.
Dustin G.

Tried the breaded pork tenderloin as I continue my tenderloin trail. The tenderloin was very well executed. Very tender and the breading was not overpowering. The onion rings were amazing. My lunch partner had the tuna melt and rated it a 7 out of 10, saying if the bread was different the rating would have been higher. It was definitely loaded with tuna. The banana cream pie was large, but honestly did not live up to the hype. It was OK, but the bananas were almost an afterthought not having been throughout the pie and clearly without time to have the flavors meld together like a good banana cream pudding. Gray Brothers cafeteria's banana pie is not as large but is better.

Location

Welcome to Muldoon's on Main, a delightful New American pub nestled at 111 W Main St, Carmel, IN. This vibrant eatery stands out not just for its flavorful menu but for its warm, inviting atmosphere, ideal for families, friends, and casual gatherings.

What Makes Muldoon's Shine:

  • Diverse Menu: From mouthwatering appetizers like the Buffalo Chicken Wings and Skewered Fried Cheese to refreshing salads such as the Crab Cake Salad and Black Bleu Salad, there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to indulge in their delectable desserts like the Chocolate Volcano Cake.
  • Community Vibes: As a women-owned establishment, Muldoon's fosters a strong sense of community. Whether you're laughing with friends over a Grilled Chicken Quesadilla or enjoying a drink at the bar, the friendly staff, including noted favorites like Dawn and Brenda, make sure you feel right at home.
  • Fun Atmosphere: With casual outdoor seating, a pool table, and even live music, this is the perfect spot to unwind. Many patrons have praised the moderate noise level, allowing for good conversation without shouting.
  • Accessibility: Muldoon’s is fully wheelchair accessible and offers a variety of payment options including cryptocurrency. Plus, they are pet-friendly, ensuring everyone in your party feels welcomed.

Customer Experience:

Erin S. captures the spirit well: “Booze? - check. Friendly staff? - check. Super tasty chicken quesadilla? - check.” This sentiment is echoed throughout various reviews highlighting the flavorful food, strong drinks, and great company found at Muldoon’s. Julian H. also raves about the Sunday Brunch, emphasizing not just the value but the quality.

Whether it’s a casual lunch or a lively dinner with friends, Muldoon’s on Main provides a culinary experience infused with a welcoming spirit. Stop by for Happy Hour specials on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday—your tastebuds will thank you!

For reservations, call (317) 571-1116 and get ready to savor the best of New American cuisine in a cozy pub setting. Don’t miss out on this local gem!